Wow, I can’t believe this really is review #29! Hawthornehedge/Christine, In my opinion your own opinion towards idea of Mr. Age, that “it is possible not always a given”, is in fact based on the main area I became trying to make on the fanon theories overall. I am not saying some of the ideas We elevated to own dialogue Are not plausible, exactly that these are typically from the truly the only possible perceptions out-of canon. It appears many people assume that just because a great deal of fanfics or fansites support a theory, one itself is actually evidence that the concept is right. And sign on the concept also, if in case “a lot of almost every other fans cannot be completely wrong”, and you will, specially when you are considering fanfic, try influences me personally because the nearly idle.
Yards do actually share with his son you to however wished to wed an other woman; I believe your own “offhand remark” theory and you may TTB’s theory he try idealizing his first, shed love, are both possible
I additionally don’t know just how certainly she intended for us to simply take Peeta’s memory, 11 ages later on, off something which happened as he try five years dated. Katniss by herself cannot seem to at first, inquiring, “Therefore, given that we were four, that you do not even observed other girls? Indeed I really don’t imagine the idea you to definitely “Mr. M permanently enjoyed Mrs. Age, to the point he duped with the their spouse along with her, and you will Demure are the end result”, was actually ever based! We actually do not know just how abusive Mrs. Meters actually was, or how miserable Mr. Yards actually was inside the relationships. Katniss notices you to bout of actual and you can spoken discipline, and you may Peeta records one episode of verbal abuse. Mrs. Yards together with appears to have a general character because an effective “witch”.
M didn’t come with fascination with their own after all and just wound up kissbrides.com korisni resursi with their unique due to an arranged matrimony
But that does not mean Mr. In the real-world, Lots of women big date, get married, and certainly will profess undying love for guys that are abusive so you’re able to their lovers and you will students. They generate reasons on the abuse, and you can perform discover the idea of cheating on the lover repugnant. Very, I do not pick any reason as to why it goes without saying you to an excellent people hitched so you’re able to an abusive woman carry out joyfully cheat on her, anymore than just a lady married so you’re able to an abusive guy do. For as to why Mr.
I really believe one to Mr. M’s choices is largely probable where a number of abusive or disappointed marriage ceremonies, moms and dads will move to their college students, maybe not brand new mate, getting emotional service, and often grumble about the mate to the kid. Mr. Yards will not really do that. But keep in mind that Peeta’s a reaction to his father’s confession, is actually “Good coal miner? As to why performed she need good coal miner in the event the she could’ve had your? When it comes to Seam/Seller divide, In my opinion another important element of brand new “Prim is actually Mr. M’s youngster” principle is a presumption the Everdeens have been the initial cross-class partners to help you actually can be found from inside the D12, which there isn’t any means Mr. Everdeen might have had blonde, blue-eyed forefathers who passed away those genes so you can your, and whoever genetics the guy eventually passed to help you Demure.
We lso are-take a look at the element of THG in which P and you may K talk about one to, and you may Peeta indeed will not appear to imagine it had been an enormous deal: “I’m sure who does excitement your parents, you preference an excellent girl throughout the Seam,” I say. But I didn’t proper care shorter. Anyhow, when we succeed straight back, you might not become a girl about Seam, you will end up an excellent girl about Victor’s Town,” he states. Peeta’s mother conveyed anti-Seam bigotry whenever she tries to pursue Katniss away, and Peeta’s dad got an individual reasoning to dislike people from this new Seam, or at least not want his sons marrying individuals following that. But that doesn’t mean *all* Provider families would have tossed a match in the event the an infant old otherwise hitched from their classification, disowned them, an such like.